Magic: The Gathering cards on PSA's stolen list

PSA's list of 6,451 stolen certs includes 8 Magic: The Gathering slabs (<1% of the list).

Check a cert Search every stolen card

Evidence inventory

STOLEN10.13.26

Slabs stolen: 8
Unique cards: 8

Priced: 6 of 8; SlabHeist estimates from cited public sales, checked Oct 24, 2026. How we price cards
Priced slabs: $45K to $46K; The 75% of slabs we have priced, valued at PSA 8 to PSA 10, or the nearest grade with a cited sale. Grades are unknown, so this is a range, not a total.
Years: 2025 to 2026; Oldest: Lightning, Army of One, 2025 Magic: The Gathering Final Fantasy #0545

Source: PSA's list of stolen certs (PDF), published October 23, 2026. SlabHeist is not affiliated with PSA.

Every Magic: The Gathering card on the list

All 8, the 6 with a SlabHeist estimate first. The rest say Price check pending until we can cite public sales of them.

Buying a Magic: The Gathering slab?

Check the cert first. Paste one number or a whole list and we match it against all 6,451 certs PSA deactivated after the theft. If it is on the list, do not buy it.

What was taken

The 8 Magic: The Gathering slabs on PSA's list, counted.

Sets with the most slabs

Final Fantasy20255slabs
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal20251slab
Promos20251slab
The Hobbit20261slab

SlabHeist

Magic: The Gathering cards on PSA's stolen list

Every Magic: The Gathering card on the list

Smaug the Magnificent · Gleaming Gold

Lightning, Army of One

Squall, Seed Mercenary

Noctis, Prince of Lucis

Ardyn, the Usurper

Seifer Almasy

Aang, Air Nomad

Aang's Shelter

Buying a Magic: The Gathering slab?

What was taken

Sets with the most slabs

More from the list