Skip to content
SlabHeist
Check

SlabHeist

A public tracker of the slabs stolen on October 13, 2026.

Get Updates

Willie McCovey, 1960 Topps #316 · All-Star Rookie

PSA 9$17,700est. See values by grade2stolenBaseballRookie
Likely matchStolen copies' grades unknown
Check a cert

PSA's description

1960 TOPPS 316 WILLIE McCOVEY ALL-STAR ROOKIE

DECERTIFIED

Status as of PSA deactivated all 2 certs. No recoveries have been reported.In your own PSA order? What PSA is paying owners

Value by grade

Each estimate is the median, the middle price, of the public sales we found of this card at that grade.

PSA 10 estimate
No sales
PSA 9 estimate
$17,700
PSA 8 estimate
$3,360

Sales behind each estimate

  • PSA 93 sales, $15,600 to $24,400
  • PSA 83 sales, $3,300 to $3,700

If both copies are PSA 8, about $6,720 together; if both are PSA 9, about $35,400. PSA's list does not give the grades of the stolen copies.

SlabHeist estimates from 6 public sales (3 at PSA 9, 3 at PSA 8). Checked .Likely match
Listings we matched1
  • 1960 Topps #316 Willie McCovey All-Star Rookie (RC)
How we price cards

See it on the market

Any listing could be one of the stolen slabs. Check the cert before you pay.

Sales history

The public sales behind the estimates. Prices are as sold, rounded to the dollar.

6 public sales of Willie McCovey, 1960 Topps #316 between Dec 13, 2024 and Aug 23, 2026. PSA 9: estimate $17,700, the median of 3 sales. PSA 8: estimate $3,360, the median of 3 sales. Use the arrow keys to move between sales.

Tap a dot to see the sale. Point at a dot to see the sale, click it to keep it open. The price scale is logarithmic so every grade fits.

Public sales of Willie McCovey, 1960 Topps #316, newest first
SoldVenueGradePriceListing
Heritage AuctionsPSA 9Heritage AuctionsPSA 9$24,400
eBayPSA 8eBayPSA 8$3,700
eBayPSA 8eBayPSA 8$3,300
Fanatics CollectPSA 9Fanatics CollectPSA 9$17,700
Fanatics CollectPSA 8Fanatics CollectPSA 8$3,360
Heritage AuctionsPSA 9Heritage AuctionsPSA 9$15,600

Stolen cert numbers for this card

PSA deactivated all 2. A slab that shows any of these numbers is on the stolen list. Each number opens in the cert checker, and PSA beside it opens PSA's own page for that cert.

Open all 2 in the checker

If you are offered this slab

  1. Do not buy it, and do not confront the seller.
  2. Write down the cert number, the listing or the seller's name, and where and when you saw it.
  3. Report it. The Santa Ana Police Department and the FBI are investigating, and PSA asks for tips to go to them.

A thief can crack a card out of its slab and sell it raw, so a valuable copy of this card with no cert is not in the clear. Ask where it came from.

Phone numbers from PSA's theft update, October 23, 2026.

Card details

Category
Baseball
Year
1960
Brand
Topps
Set
Topps
Number
#316
Variant
All-Star Rookie
Language
English
Marked
Rookie
Stolen
2 slabs on PSA's list