Aaron Judge cards on PSA's stolen list
PSA grades cards and seals each one in a plastic case, called a slab.
22 slabs of Aaron Judge were stolen: 19 different cards, from 2014 to 2026.
The top card is Aaron Judge, 2022 Topps Home Field Advantage #HA7. A PSA 10 copy sells for about $1,875.
Evidence inventory
STOLEN10.13.26- Slabs stolen
- 22
- Unique cards
- 19
- Priced slabs
- $4K to $9.8K
- Every slab here, from all at PSA 8 to all at PSA 10 (or the nearest grade that sold). We don't know their grades, so this is a range.
Source: PSA's list of stolen certs (PDF), published October 23, 2026. SlabHeist is not affiliated with PSA.
Every Aaron Judge card on the list
All 19, most valuable first.
- #1.
Aaron Judge
2022 Topps Home Field Advantage #HA7
Est. value- PSA 10
- $1.9K
- PSA 9
- $235
- PSA 8
- $157
- #2.
Aaron Judge
2017 Topps Heritage #214, Rookie
Est. value- PSA 10
- $1.6K
- PSA 9
- $800
- PSA 8
- #3.
Aaron Judge
2018 Topps Gypsy Queen Autograph #GQAAJ
Est. value- PSA 10
- $1.5K
- PSA 9
- PSA 8
- #4.
Aaron Judge
2025 Topps Chrome World Series at Night #WSN6
Est. value- PSA 10
- $900
- PSA 9
- $365
- PSA 8
- $400
- #5.
Aaron Judge
2017 Bowman Chrome #56
Est. value- PSA 10
- $502
- PSA 9
- $210
- PSA 8
- $150
- #6.
Aaron Judge
2026 Topps Heavy Lumber #3
Est. value- PSA 10
- $430
- PSA 9
- $160
- PSA 8
- $107
- #7.
Aaron Judge
2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit #1, Sun
Est. value- PSA 10
- $390
- PSA 9
- $140
- PSA 8
- $100
- #8.
Aaron Judge
2017 Topps Chrome #169
Est. value- PSA 10
- $350
- PSA 9
- $174
- PSA 8
- $141
- #9.
Aaron Judge · Asia Black
2014 Bowman Draft Picks Top Prospects #TP39
Est. value- PSA 10
- $326
- PSA 9
- $85
- PSA 8
- $28
- #10.
Aaron Judge
2017 Panini Chronicles Panini Prizm #1
Est. value- PSA 10
- $318
- PSA 9
- $92
- PSA 8
- $55
- #11.
Aaron Judge
2017 Topps Opening Day #147
Est. value- PSA 10
- $200
- PSA 9
- $60
- PSA 8
- $26
- #12.
Aaron Judge
2017 Topps Update #US99
Est. value- PSA 10
- $200
- PSA 9
- $65
- PSA 8
- $41
- #13.
Aaron Judge · Gold Refractor
2022 Topps Allen & Ginter Chrome #11
Est. value- PSA 10
- $169
- PSA 9
- PSA 8
- #14.
Aaron Judge
2015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects #TP-21
Est. value- PSA 10
- $125
- PSA 9
- $63
- PSA 8
- #15.
Aaron Judge
2025 Panini Crusade Numbers #15
Est. value- PSA 10
- $100
- PSA 9
- $33
- PSA 8
- $50
- #16.
Aaron Judge
2015 Bowman Draft #150
Est. value- PSA 10
- $99
- PSA 9
- $35
- PSA 8
- $34
- #17.
Aaron Judge
2014 Bowman Draft Picks Top Prospects #TP39
Est. value- PSA 10
- $96
- PSA 9
- $40
- PSA 8
- $26
- #18.
Aaron Judge
2026 Topps Titans of the Game #3
Est. value- PSA 10
- $82
- PSA 9
- $21
- PSA 8
- $18
- #19.
Aaron Judge
2024 Topps Big League to the Moon Die-Cuts #TM21
Est. value- PSA 10
- $63
- PSA 9
- $30
- PSA 8
- 5.Aaron Judge, 2017 Bowman Chrome #56BaseballYear 20171stolenPSA 10 $502PSA 9 $210PSA 8 $150PSA 10 estimate $502PSA 9 $210PSA 8 $1501stolen
- 6.Aaron Judge, 2026 Topps Heavy Lumber #3BaseballYear 20261stolenPSA 10 $430, 1 salePSA 9 $160PSA 8 $107PSA 10 estimate $430PSA 9 $160PSA 8 $107, 1 sale1stolen
- 7.Aaron Judge, 2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit #1BaseballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $390PSA 9 $140PSA 8 $100PSA 10 estimate $390PSA 9 $140PSA 8 $1001stolen
- 8.Aaron Judge, 2017 Topps Chrome #169BaseballYear 20171stolenPSA 10 $350PSA 9 $174PSA 8 $141PSA 10 estimate $350PSA 9 $174PSA 8 $1411stolen
- 9.Aaron Judge · Asia Black, 2014 Bowman Draft Picks Top Prospects #TP39BaseballYear 20142stolenPSA 10 $326PSA 9 $85PSA 8 $28PSA 10 estimate $326PSA 9 $85PSA 8 $282stolen
- 10.Aaron Judge, 2017 Panini Chronicles Panini Prizm #1BaseballYear 20171stolenPSA 10 $318PSA 9 $92PSA 8 $55PSA 10 estimate $318PSA 9 $92PSA 8 $551stolen
- 11.Aaron Judge, 2017 Topps Opening Day #147BaseballYear 20171stolenPSA 10 $200PSA 9 $60PSA 8 $26PSA 10 estimate $200PSA 9 $60PSA 8 $261stolen
- 12.Aaron Judge, 2017 Topps Update #US99BaseballYear 20171stolenPSA 10 $200PSA 9 $65PSA 8 $41PSA 10 estimate $200PSA 9 $65PSA 8 $411stolen
- 13.Aaron Judge · Gold Refractor, 2022 Topps Allen & Ginter Chrome #11BaseballYear 20221stolenPSA 10 $169, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $169, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
- 14.Aaron Judge, 2015 Bowman's Best Top Prospects #TP-21BaseballYear 20151stolenPSA 10 $125PSA 9 $63PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $125PSA 9 $631stolen
- 15.Aaron Judge, 2025 Panini Crusade Numbers #15BaseballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $100PSA 9 $33PSA 8 $50PSA 10 estimate $100PSA 9 $33PSA 8 $501stolen
- 16.Aaron Judge, 2015 Bowman Draft #150BaseballYear 20152stolenPSA 10 $99PSA 9 $35PSA 8 $34PSA 10 estimate $99PSA 9 $35PSA 8 $342stolen
- 17.Aaron Judge, 2014 Bowman Draft Picks Top Prospects #TP39BaseballYear 20142stolenPSA 10 $96PSA 9 $40PSA 8 $26PSA 10 estimate $96PSA 9 $40PSA 8 $262stolen
- 18.Aaron Judge, 2026 Topps Titans of the Game #3BaseballYear 20261stolenPSA 10 $82, 1 salePSA 9 $21PSA 8 $18PSA 10 estimate $82PSA 9 $21PSA 8 $18, 1 sale1stolen
- 19.Aaron Judge, 2024 Topps Big League to the Moon Die-Cuts #TM21BaseballYear 20241stolenPSA 10 $63, Likely matchPSA 9 $30PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $63PSA 9 $30, Likely match1stolen
Buying a Aaron Judge slab?
Check its cert number first. That is the number on the case. If it is on the list, do not buy it.
What was taken
All 22 slabs, counted.