Tyler Shough cards on PSA's stolen list
PSA grades cards and seals each one in a plastic case, called a slab.
13 slabs of Tyler Shough were stolen: 13 different cards, all from 2025.
The top card is Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Donruss Optic Uptown #24. A PSA 10 copy sells for about $903.
Evidence inventory
STOLEN10.13.26- Slabs stolen
- 13
- Unique cards
- 13
- Priced slabs
- $1.8K to $3.9K
- The 92% we have prices for, from all at PSA 8 to all at PSA 10 (or the nearest grade that sold). We don't know their grades, so this is a range.
Source: PSA's list of stolen certs (PDF), published October 23, 2026. SlabHeist is not affiliated with PSA.
Every Tyler Shough card on the list
All 13, most valuable first. We have no price yet for the rest.
- #1.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Donruss Optic Uptown #24
Est. value- PSA 10
- $903
- PSA 9
- $325
- PSA 8
- $204
- #2.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Phoenix Color Blast #1
Est. value- PSA 10
- $700
- PSA 9
- $275
- PSA 8
- $260
- #3.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Select #141, Zebra Shock
Est. value- PSA 10
- $625
- PSA 9
- PSA 8
- #4.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Select Rookie Signatures #RSI-TSH
Est. value- PSA 10
- $407
- PSA 9
- $185
- PSA 8
- #5.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Score #71, Rookie, Signature
Est. value- PSA 10
- $301
- PSA 9
- $60
- PSA 8
- $17
- #6.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Phoenix Archetype #3
Est. value- PSA 10
- $210
- PSA 9
- $100
- PSA 8
- $36
- #7.
Tyler Shough
2025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition Sapphire Selections #SS-18
Est. value- PSA 10
- PSA 9
- $165
- PSA 8
- #8.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Phoenix Phoenician #17
Est. value- PSA 10
- $153
- PSA 9
- $90
- PSA 8
- $45
- #9.
Tyler Shough · Pulsar
2025 Topps Chrome #398
Est. value- PSA 10
- $150
- PSA 9
- $32
- PSA 8
- $25
- #10.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Absolute #194, Signature
Est. value- PSA 10
- $116
- PSA 9
- $70
- PSA 8
- #11.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Select #41, Neon Green Shock
Est. value- PSA 10
- $108
- PSA 9
- PSA 8
- #12.
Tyler Shough
2025 Topps Chrome #398
Est. value- PSA 10
- $87
- PSA 9
- $45
- PSA 8
- $24
- #13.
Tyler Shough
2025 Panini Donruss Optic #223, Autograph, Holo
Price check pending
- 5.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Score #71FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $301, Likely matchPSA 9 $60PSA 8 $17, 1 salePSA 10 estimate $301PSA 9 $60PSA 8 $17, Likely match1stolen
- 6.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Phoenix Archetype #3FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $210PSA 9 $100, 1 salePSA 8 $36, 1 salePSA 10 estimate $210PSA 9 $100PSA 8 $361stolen
- 7.Tyler Shough, 2025 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition Sapphire Selections #SS-18FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 PSA 9 $165, Likely matchPSA 8 PSA 9 estimate $165, Likely match1stolen
- 8.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Phoenix Phoenician #17FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $153, Likely matchPSA 9 $90, 1 salePSA 8 $45, 1 salePSA 10 estimate $153PSA 9 $90PSA 8 $45, Likely match1stolen
- 9.Tyler Shough · Pulsar, 2025 Topps Chrome #398FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $150PSA 9 $32PSA 8 $25, 1 salePSA 10 estimate $150PSA 9 $32PSA 8 $251stolen
- 10.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Absolute #194FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $116, Likely matchPSA 9 $70, 1 salePSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $116PSA 9 $70, Likely match1stolen
- 11.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Select #41FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $108, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $108, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
- 12.Tyler Shough, 2025 Topps Chrome #398FootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $87PSA 9 $45PSA 8 $24PSA 10 estimate $87PSA 9 $45PSA 8 $241stolen
- 13.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Donruss Optic #223FootballYear 20251stolenPrice check pendingPending1stolen
Buying a Tyler Shough slab?
Check its cert number first. That is the number on the case. If it is on the list, do not buy it.
What was taken
All 13 slabs, counted.