Skip to content
Check

SlabHeist

Tracking the cards stolen on October 13, 2026.

Get Updates

2025 Panini Select cards on PSA's stolen list

PSA grades cards and seals each one in a plastic case, called a slab.

31 slabs from 2025 Panini Select were stolen: 31 different cards.

The top card is Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Select #141. A PSA 10 copy sells for about $625.

Check a certSearch these cards

Evidence inventory

STOLEN10.13.26
Slabs stolen
31
Unique cards
31
Priced
17 of 31
From real public sales, checked Oct 24, 2026. How we price cards
Priced slabs
$1.7K to $2.4K
The 55% we have prices for, from all at PSA 8 to all at PSA 10 (or the nearest grade that sold). We don't know their grades, so this is a range.

Source: PSA's list of stolen certs (PDF), published October 23, 2026. SlabHeist is not affiliated with PSA.

Most valuable 2025 Panini Select cards

PSA grades cards from 1 to 10, and 10 is the best. We rank by the PSA 10 price, or 9 or 8 if no 10 has sold.

  1. 5.Colston Loveland · Light Blue Prizm, 2025 Panini Select #172FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $160, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 $30, 1 salePSA 8 $13, 1 salePSA 10 estimate $160PSA 9 $30PSA 8 $13, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
  2. 6.Cam Skattebo, 2025 Panini Select #294FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $108PSA 9 PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $1081stolen
  3. 7.Tyler Shough, 2025 Panini Select #41FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $108, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $108, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
  4. 8.Patrick Mahomes II, 2025 Panini Select #107FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $105, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 $25PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $105PSA 9 $25, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
  5. 9.Ashton Jeanty · Silver Prizm, 2025 Panini Select #104FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $100PSA 9 $26, 1 salePSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $100PSA 9 $261stolen
  6. 10.Matthew Golden, 2025 Panini Select #267FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $90, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 9 PSA 8 PSA 10 estimate $90, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
  7. 11.Justin Jefferson, 2025 Panini Select #163FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 PSA 9 $85, 1 sale, Likely matchPSA 8 PSA 9 estimate $85, 1 sale, Likely match1stolen
  8. 12.Cam Ward, 2025 Panini Select #26FootballFootballYear 20251stolenPSA 10 $79PSA 9 $23PSA 8 $14PSA 10 estimate $79PSA 9 $23PSA 8 $141stolen

Buying a 2025 Panini Select slab?

Check its cert number first. That is the number on the case. If it is on the list, do not buy it.

The number printed on the slab label.

What was taken

All 31 slabs, counted.

Players with the most slabs

  1. Jaxson Dart3slabs
  2. Ashton Jeanty2slabs
  3. Colston Loveland2slabs
  4. Puka Nacua2slabs
  5. Tyler Shough2slabs

Every 2025 Panini Select card on the list

Search them by name, or sort them by value.

See all 31

More from the list