Skip to content

Bought a stolen PSA slab? What to do now

The cert on a slab you bought is on PSA’s stolen list. Keep it as it is, report it, and ask for your money back before the marketplace’s deadline runs out.

By SlabHeistPublished Facts as of 6 min read

On this page

Short version

  • Keep the slab as it is. Do not crack it, sell it on or send it back on your own.
  • Save the listing, the seller’s details and your receipt, then report it to the FBI or Santa Ana police.
  • Ask the marketplace or your card company for your money back soon. Some deadlines are days, not months.
  • Generally, under US law, a buyer cannot get good title to goods from a thief, so expect the slab to go back to its owner. PSA’s own guarantee does not cover it.

You already paid for a slab, and now its cert number is on PSA’s list (opens in a new tab) of 6,451 certs stolen from a FedEx truck on Oct 13, 2026. Here is what to do, in order. Some refund deadlines run out within days, so do not wait.

First, check the number again. Type it exactly as it is printed on the front of the label, lower right.

Check a cert now

Checks all 6,451 certs on PSA’s list. Paste one number or a list.

The number printed on the slab label.

Make sure it is a match

  • Check every digit. One wrong digit gives you a different cert. If the checker says the number does not look like a cert from this theft, look at the label again.
  • Look it up on PSA too. Type the number into psacard.com/cert (opens in a new tab). Reports differ on what a stolen cert shows there: Mantel (opens in a new tab) says decertified, and Tech Times (opens in a new tab) says the search comes back blank. Neither says why. Our PSA cert lookup guide covers numbers that will not look up.
  • A match does not make the seller a thief. It means PSA turned the cert off. On Oct 27, slabs with turned-off certs turned up in one eBay seller’s store. Resell Calendar (opens in a new tab) found the listings were made before the theft and concluded the seller was one of the victims.

What to do, step by step

  1. Keep the slab as it is. Do not take the card out of its case, and do not sell it on. eBay’s stolen property policy (opens in a new tab) says "the sale of stolen property is not allowed on eBay", and Whatnot’s rules (opens in a new tab) ban stolen items too. On Fanatics Collect, "any manipulation of the collectible, grading slab, or certificate" voids its guarantee.
  2. Save everything. Take screenshots of the listing now, because sellers can take listings down. Keep the seller’s name or username, your messages, the receipt, the payment record, the shipping label and the box it came in.
  3. Report it. PSA’s update asks for tips to go to the FBI in Los Angeles. eBay’s policy also says to "contact local law enforcement immediately" about stolen property you see on eBay. Ask for a report number. PayPal says it may ask for police reports.
  4. Ask for your money back. Open a claim with the marketplace, PayPal or your card company. Deadlines are in the table below. Say the cert is on PSA’s list of stolen certs, and give the date PSA published it, Oct 23, 2026.
  5. Tell PSA. PSA’s terms (opens in a new tab) say: "If you possess a deactivated cert, please contact our Customer Care team for direction."

Refund deadlines

None of these rules names stolen slabs. They cover items that are not as described or not authentic, and each company decides if a slab with a turned-off cert counts. Ask anyway, and ask early. We read these rules on Nov 4, 2026, from copies saved between October 2025 and October 2026, so check each company’s page for changes.

  • eBay. Its Money Back Guarantee (opens in a new tab) covers an item not as described. For trading cards, ask within the seller’s return window, or within 3 days of delivery if the seller takes no returns. eBay also says some purchases inspected under its Authenticity Guarantee are "considered final sale", and its guarantee "does not cover final sale purchases on the basis that the item doesn’t match the listing".
  • PayPal. Purchase Protection (opens in a new tab) covers an item "significantly not as described". You have 30 days after delivery or 180 days after you paid, whichever comes first.
  • Whatnot. Buyer Protection (opens in a new tab) covers an item that "isn’t what you purchased". For sports cards and trading card games, you have 7 days after delivery or 30 days after purchase, whichever comes first. For an item you suspect is fake, you have 30 days after it arrives.
  • Fanatics Collect. "All sales are final", its policy (opens in a new tab) says. It cancels a sale only for an item "inconsistent with the asset description", and only within 48 hours of delivery.
  • Credit card. You can dispute a billing error (opens in a new tab). Your letter must reach the card company within 60 days of the statement that shows the charge.

Choose your route with care, because some cannot be undone. Whatnot says orders "disputed with a financial institution are not eligible for refunds". PayPal says you "can’t do both" a PayPal claim and a card dispute at the same time. While a claim is open, keep an eye on your card company’s 60 days.

If you bought at a card show, a shop or through a social media post, ask the seller for a refund first and keep a record of what they say. If you paid by credit card, the card company’s 60 days still apply.

Should you send it back to the seller?

Not on your own. A slab sent back to the person who sold it can go straight back on sale. Report it first. If a marketplace or PayPal asks you to ship it, tell them the cert is on PSA’s stolen list and ask where it should go. PayPal’s rules say it may ask you to ship an item "to the seller, to PayPal or to a third party".

Can you keep it?

Most likely not. Generally, under US law, "a person cannot get good title to goods from a thief", as a business law textbook (opens in a new tab) puts it, so the owner can claim the card. PSA’s update says "recovering every stolen item and returning it to its owner is our top priority". When stolen items turn up, it says, their owners can keep the payout they got or take the item back.

So plan on the slab going back to its owner, and on your money coming from the seller, the marketplace or your card company. Resell Calendar warns that if a stolen card is traced to you, "you’d likely have to return the card to its rightful owner without getting your money back". That is why the refund deadlines above matter. This page is not legal advice. For a costly slab, ask a lawyer.

PSA’s financial guarantee (opens in a new tab) does not cover it either. It "does not apply to cards where the certification number has been deactivated by PSA before the most recent purchase", and it "does not apply to lost, stolen, or damaged Items".

If you paid for one that never came

Some sellers list slabs before the slabs reach them. If you paid for one that was on the truck, it never arrived, and the seller lost it too. The seller in the Resell Calendar story said the cards "often get listed automatically after shipment" and "unfortunately never arrived". Ask the seller for a refund. PayPal gives you 180 days after you paid to claim an item that never arrived.

If you bought it raw

A raw card has no cert, so our checker cannot match it. If a card you bought raw is on our list of stolen cards, our buyer’s guide shows how to check when its listing was first made.

What our checker covers

Our checker covers only the October 2026 truck theft. A clean result means the number is not on PSA’s list from that theft. SlabHeist is not affiliated with PSA or Collectors Universe.

Questions people ask

What should I do if I bought a stolen PSA slab?

Keep the slab as it is and do not sell it. Save the listing, the seller’s details and your receipt. Report it to the FBI in Los Angeles, where PSA asks tips to go, or to Santa Ana police. Then ask the marketplace or your card company for a refund before its deadline.

Can I get a refund for a stolen PSA slab?

You can ask, but act fast. eBay, PayPal, Whatnot and Fanatics Collect cover items that are not as described, though none of their rules names stolen slabs. Some deadlines are short: 48 hours after delivery to cancel on Fanatics Collect, 7 days for sports cards on Whatnot, and on eBay the seller’s return window for trading cards, or 3 days if the seller takes no returns. A credit card dispute must reach the card company within 60 days of the statement.

Do I have to give back a stolen PSA slab?

Most likely. Generally, under US law a buyer cannot get good title to goods from a thief, so the owner can claim the card. PSA says that when stolen items are recovered, their owners can choose the card or the payout they got. This is not legal advice. For a costly slab, ask a lawyer.

Does PSA’s guarantee cover a slab with a deactivated cert?

No. PSA’s financial guarantee does not apply to cards whose cert PSA turned off before you bought them, or to stolen items. PSA’s terms ask anyone holding a deactivated cert to contact its Customer Care team for direction.

Should I send the slab back to the seller?

Not on your own. A slab sent back to the seller can go straight back on sale. Report it first. If a marketplace asks you to ship it, tell them the cert is on PSA’s stolen list and ask where it should go.

Does a stolen cert mean the seller is the thief?

No. It means PSA turned the cert off. Some sellers were victims of the theft themselves, and a slab can change hands several times. Leave the question of who stole it to the police.

Sources

  1. PSA theft updatepsacard.com
  2. PSA terms and conditionspsacard.com
  3. PSA financial guaranteepsacard.com
  4. eBay Money Back Guaranteeebay.com
  5. eBay stolen property policyebay.com
  6. PayPal Purchase Protectionpaypal.com
  7. Whatnot Buyer Protectionhelp.whatnot.com
  8. Fanatics Collect returnshelp.fanaticscollect.com
  9. CFPB on credit card refundsconsumerfinance.gov
  10. Saylor Academy, title from nonownerssaylordotorg.github.io
  11. Resell Calendar, eBay listingsresellcalendar.com
  12. Mantel via Yahoo Sportssports.yahoo.com
  13. Tech Timestechtimes.com
  14. psacard.com/certpsacard.com
  15. Whatnot’s ruleshelp.whatnot.com

SlabHeist is independent and not affiliated with PSA or Collectors. Spotted an error? hello@slabheist.com

Keep reading

Check before you buy

Paste one cert or a list to see if it is on PSA’s stolen list. Or look through every stolen card.

Get case updates

One short email when the investigation moves or recovered slabs are named. Confirm by link, leave any time.

We save your sign-up now; confirmation emails start soon.