Skip to content

Free ways to check if a PSA slab is stolen

The free tools that check a PSA cert for theft, side by side: what each costs, if it needs an account, and if it has PSA’s list from the October 2026 theft.

By SlabHeistUpdated Facts as of 7 min read

On this page

Short version

  • Run two free checks on any PSA slab: PSA’s own cert lookup, then a stolen list.
  • Five free tools check a cert against PSA’s list of the 6,451 certs stolen on Oct 13, 2026: SlabHeist, CheckCOA, GTCR, CollectorRecovery and PreGradeCards.
  • For other thefts, GTCR, CheckCOA, Kapture, CardLegit and CardChase hold reports sent in by collectors or shops.
  • No check catches a card taken out of its slab, a fake label that copies a real cert number, or a theft nobody reported.

Thieves took at least 6,451 PSA items from a FedEx truck on Oct 13, 2026, and PSA (opens in a new tab) turned off every cert number on its list. Several free tools now check a cert against that list, and a few also hold reports of other thefts. On Nov 6, 2026, we tried each tool that lets you search with no account, using a cert from PSA’s list and a number that is not on it. PSA’s own lookup blocked our test, and Kapture and CardLegit ask for an account, so for those we went by their own pages. Prices and features change, so look again before you rely on one.

SlabHeist is one of these tools. We say where others do more.

Check a cert now

Checks all 6,451 certs on PSA’s list. Paste one number or a list.

The number printed on the slab label.

The free checkers side by side

Does it check PSA’s list?

Tool PSA’s list? Account?
PSA lookup Decertified No
PSA’s PDF Is the list No
SlabHeist Yes No
CheckCOA Yes After 1 check
GTCR Yes No
CollectorRecovery Yes No
PreGradeCards Yes No
Kapture Not confirmed To join
CardLegit Not confirmed Yes
CardChase No No

"PSA’s list?" means the tool flagged a cert from PSA’s list of the October 2026 theft and cleared 123456789, which is not on it, when we tried it on Nov 6. PSA’s own lookup shows a stolen cert as decertified, Mantel reports. CheckCOA runs a first check with no account, then asks for a free one.

What it costs, and other thefts

Tool Cost Other thefts?
PSA lookup Free Shows no reason
PSA’s PDF Free No
SlabHeist Free No
CheckCOA 15 free a month Yes
GTCR Free Yes
CollectorRecovery Free Some
PreGradeCards Free No
Kapture Free to join Yes
CardLegit 30 free a month Yes
CardChase Free Shop break-ins

Start with PSA’s own lookup

Type the number into PSA’s Cert Verification page (opens in a new tab) and make sure the year, card, name and grade match the slab. PSA has turned off every cert stolen from the truck, and those show as decertified, Mantel reports (opens in a new tab). The page does not say why a cert was turned off, so run a stolen-list check too.

A real record does not prove a real slab. PSA’s own lookup page warns that "criminals do attempt to counterfeit PSA grading inserts using actual certification numbers derived from public sources." Our PSA cert lookup guide shows where the number is and what PSA’s record can tell you.

Tools that check PSA’s October 2026 list

SlabHeist (this site). Free, with no account. Type one cert, scan the label or paste up to 500 numbers from a listing or a spreadsheet. The check runs on your own phone or computer, and our site stats do not keep the numbers. Each stolen card has its own page with every stolen cert for it. We cover only this theft.

CheckCOA. CheckCOA (opens in a new tab) checks a cert against the records of 25 or more graders and autograph authenticators, and its own fraud reports, so it also catches other problems. It flags this theft: all 5 certs from PSA’s list we tried came back "Stolen card: this cert is on PSA’s list of cards stolen from a FedEx truck carrying PSA orders." A first check works with no account. After that, the free plan (opens in a new tab) gives 15 checks a month, 5 a day. Paid plans start at $7.99 a month billed yearly, or $9.99 month to month, and a CSV upload of many certs is on the Dealer plan, $39.99 a month billed yearly. CheckCOA says that from Jan 1, 2027, the full evidence behind a fraud alert becomes a paid feature for new free accounts, and that "Everyone still sees the verdict for free."

GTCR. The Global Trading Card Registry (opens in a new tab) comes from the Certified Trading Card Association, a nonprofit. It is free and needs no account to search. It says "All PSA Graded Cards Involved in Heist Are Registered in the GTCR", and its home page search flagged a cert from PSA’s list in our test. It also holds reports of other thefts sent in by collectors, for PSA, Beckett, CGC, SGC and other graders. It says you can upload a spreadsheet or paste a list. We did not test that. Its own warning: "‘No Adverse Report Found’ is not a guarantee that a card has never been lost, stolen, or subject to ownership disputes."

CollectorRecovery. Its search page (opens in a new tab) checks the 6,451 certs from PSA’s list, plus community reports it says it reviews first. It flagged a cert from the list in our test. Its separate database page still said the import was pending on Nov 6, so use the search page.

PreGradeCards. A free one-cert check (opens in a new tab) for this theft only. It flagged a cert from the list in our test. The site sells AI pre-grading, and the tool is free.

PSA’s PDF. The list itself (opens in a new tab): 93 pages of cert numbers, each with PSA’s description of the card. Search it with Find. It has no grades, and checking more than a few numbers by hand is slow.

Registries for other thefts

These hold slabs reported stolen in other thefts. A slab can be clear on PSA’s list and still be in one of them.

Kapture. Free to join, with alerts by text and email when a card is reported stolen, its FAQ (opens in a new tab) says. It covers graded Pokémon, sports, Magic, One Piece and Lorcana cards. Kapture Plus (opens in a new tab), $6.99 a month or $59.99 a year, adds a camera cert scan. Its pages did not mention this theft on Nov 6, and we could not confirm it holds PSA’s list. Cardboard Journal (opens in a new tab) names it as one of three free checks to run before buying.

CardLegit. Asks you to sign up before it searches. The free plan (opens in a new tab) gives 30 checks a month for PSA, Beckett, SGC, CGC and TAG certs, and paid plans start at €49 a month. Its pages did not mention this theft, and we could not see a result without an account.

CardChase. A free registry (opens in a new tab) of slabs that card shops report stolen in break-ins. On Nov 6 it held 75 slabs, all from one shop, and none were on PSA’s list.

GTCR and CheckCOA, above, also hold reports of other thefts.

What no checker can tell you

  1. A card out of its slab has no cert. A thief can crack a slab and sell the card raw. Our buyer’s guide says what to ask about a raw copy of a stolen card.
  2. A fake label can use a real number. A clear result says nothing about the label. Scan its barcode and QR code with our label X-ray, and read how to spot a fake PSA slab.
  3. A theft nobody reported is on no list. A clear result means only that the number is not on the lists that tool checks. Even for this theft, PSA said on Nov 10 that it found more stolen parcels and turned off their certs before publishing the numbers, so check PSA’s own lookup too.
  4. A match does not make the seller a thief. Some sellers were victims of this theft themselves. If you already paid for one, read what to do if you bought a stolen PSA slab.

Which to use

Before you pay for a PSA slab:

  1. Look the cert up on PSA’s site and match the card and grade.
  2. Check it against PSA’s stolen list. Any of the five tools above will do. For a stack of certs, paste them all into SlabHeist at once.
  3. Check a registry of other thefts. GTCR covers both, free and with no account.
  4. Check the label’s codes, and ask the seller where the slab came from.

If a cert is on PSA’s list, do not buy the slab and do not confront the seller. Call one of these numbers:

Questions people ask

What is the best free way to check if a PSA slab is stolen?

Look the cert up on PSA’s site, then check it against a stolen list. For the 6,451 certs stolen in October 2026, SlabHeist, CheckCOA, GTCR, CollectorRecovery and PreGradeCards all check PSA’s list for free. GTCR and CheckCOA also hold reports of other thefts.

Does PSA’s cert lookup show if a card is stolen?

For this theft, in a way. PSA turned off all 6,451 certs, and a turned-off cert shows as decertified, the card news site Mantel reports. The page does not say why a cert was turned off, so check a stolen list as well.

Do I need an account to check a PSA cert for theft?

Not on most tools. SlabHeist, GTCR, CollectorRecovery and PreGradeCards check without one, and CheckCOA lets you run a first check without one. CardLegit asks you to sign up before it searches, and Kapture needs an account to join.

Can I check many PSA certs at once for free?

Yes. SlabHeist checks up to 500 pasted certs at once, free and with no account. GTCR says it takes a pasted list or a spreadsheet. On CheckCOA, a CSV upload is part of its paid Dealer plan.

If a slab passes every check, is it safe to buy?

Not for sure. No checker catches a card taken out of its slab, a fake label that copies a real cert number, or a theft nobody reported. Match the card to PSA’s record, check the label’s codes and ask the seller where the slab came from.

Sources

  1. PSA theft updatepsacard.com
  2. PSA’s list (PDF)assets.ctfassets.net
  3. PSA Cert Verificationpsacard.com
  4. Mantel via Yahoo Sportssports.yahoo.com
  5. CheckCOA PSA lookupcheckcoa.com
  6. CheckCOA pricingcheckcoa.com
  7. GTCRthegtcr.com
  8. CollectorRecovery searchcollectorrecovery.org
  9. PreGradeCards stolen slabs toolpregradecards.com
  10. Kapture planskapture.us
  11. Kapture FAQkapture.us
  12. CardLegit pricingcardlegit.com
  13. CardChasecardchase.org
  14. Cardboard Journalcardboardjournal.com

SlabHeist is independent and not affiliated with PSA or Collectors. Spotted an error? hello@slabheist.com

Keep reading

Check before you buy

Paste one cert or a list to see if it is on PSA’s stolen list. Or look through every stolen card.

Get case updates

One short email when the investigation moves or recovered slabs are named. Confirm by link, leave any time.

We save your sign-up now; confirmation emails start soon.