Skip to content

Stolen PSA cards sold raw: which ones can still be traced

A stolen slab can be cracked open and the card sold raw. Out of the slab, only 1/1s and numbered cards whose serial numbers owners reported can be matched.

By SlabHeistUpdated Facts as of 4 min read

On this page

Short version

  • Yes, a thief can crack a stolen slab and sell the card raw. The cert number stays with the case.
  • PSA’s list marks 20 cards as 1/1. A raw 1/1 that matches the list’s full description is very likely the stolen card.
  • The list gives no other print run, so on its own it cannot match any other raw card.
  • Owners have reported the serial number and print run of 365 stolen slabs, such as 697/777. A raw numbered card can be checked against those.
  • For a raw copy of any other card on the list, ask when the seller got it and walk away from a vague story.

Yes, a stolen PSA card can be sold raw. A thief can crack the plastic case open and sell the card on its own, with no label and no cert number. PSA deactivated (opens in a new tab) the 6,451 cert numbers taken on Oct 13, and a cert number belongs to the case, not the card. Once a slab is cracked, "there’s nothing on the card that ties it back to the theft" for most cards, Resell Calendar (opens in a new tab) points out.

PSA’s list itself has one exception you can check yourself, and owners have added a second. PSA’s list (opens in a new tab) marks 20 cards as 1/1, a print run of one.

The one-of-ones on the list

On PSA’s list the 1/1s include two Superfractors, a Padparadscha and several Platinum parallels. A raw 1/1 that matches a line on the list in full, meaning the year, set, card number and parallel, is very likely the stolen card. Check every part of the description: one player can have several different 1/1s in the same set, in other colors. Then report it, and let the police decide.

Every 1/1 on PSA’s list20 cards marked 1/1 by PSA
RankCardCategoryYearStolenPSA 10PSA 9PSA 8Est. value
1DL-BB · Ariel / Prince Eric / Jodi Benson / Christopher Daniel Barnes2026 Topps Chrome Disney Sapphire Edition Authentic Dual Autographs #DL-BBOther20261stolenPrice check pending
2Blake Snell · Gold 1/12022 Topps Dynasty Autographed Patch #DAPBS5Baseball20221stolenPrice check pending
3Gareth Bale2025 Topps Chrome MLS Topps 1995 Autographs #NFA-GBSoccer20251stolenPrice check pending
4Jaxon Smith-Njigba2025 Panini Phoenix Thunderbirds #46Football20251stolenPrice check pending
5LaMelo Ball2025 Panini Black Box #105Basketball20251stolenPrice check pending
6Mike Tyson2025 Panini Combat Anthology Sweet Science Signatures #MTYSports20251stolenPrice check pending
7Mookie Betts · Gold 1/12024 Topps Diamond Icons Single-Player Relics #SPRMBEBaseball20241stolenPrice check pending
8Randall Cunningham · Gold 1/12023 Panini Spectra Triple Threats Relics #TTRCUFootball20231stolenPrice check pending
9Roman Reigns2020 Topps WWE Transcendent VIP Party #37Wrestling20201stolenPrice check pending
10Roman Reigns2021 Topps WWE Transcendent VIP Party #28Wrestling20211stolenPrice check pending
11Roman Reigns2023 Panini Chronicles WWE #144Wrestling20231stolenPrice check pending
12Roman Reigns · Gold Vinyl 1/12023 Panini Chronicles WWE #338Wrestling20231stolenPrice check pending
13Roman Reigns2023 Panini Chronicles WWE Timeless Treasures #TT28Wrestling20231stolenPrice check pending
14Roman Reigns2023 Panini Donruss Elite WWE Elite Deck #1Wrestling20231stolenPrice check pending
15Roman Reigns · Platinum 1/12024 Panini Photogenic WWE Progressions #15Wrestling20241stolenPrice check pending
16Shohei Ohtani2026 Topps Silver Pack 1991 Chrome All-Stars #50Baseball20261stolenPrice check pending
17Stephen Curry · Gold 1/12023 Leaf Vibrance Autographs #BASC1Basketball20231stolenPrice check pending
18Takumi Minamino / Ayase Ueda · Gold Power 1/12026 Panini Prizm FIFA World Cup 2026 Dual Signatures #TASoccer20261stolenPrice check pending
19Torry Holt2025 Panini Phoenix #137Football20251stolenPrice check pending
20Trevor Lawrence · Gold 1/12025 Panini Black Box #RETLFootball20251stolenPrice check pending

Numbered cards owners reported

Owners have filled in part of what the list leaves out. They say PSA’s emails to them listed their stolen cards, and they put the numbered ones, with serial numbers, on a shared sheet (opens in a new tab) that Boston Card Hunter collected. It gives the serial number and print run of 365 stolen slabs that are on PSA’s list, the 1/1s among them.

To check a raw numbered card, search its serial on our stolen card list as one number, a slash and the print run, with no spaces, such as 697/777. If a card comes up, compare the rest of the description too: year, set, card number and parallel. A match on all of them is very likely the stolen copy, so report it as you would a 1/1.

These are the owners’ own reports, not PSA’s. A number that does not come up proves nothing: the sheet covers only the owners who chose to add their cards.

What the list does not show

PSA says its list includes "serial numbers for serialized cards". We read every line of it. The only number it gives is 1/1. It calls 7 more slabs serialized, all Dragon Ball and One Piece cards, but gives no number for them. Some parallels on the list are usually numbered, but they appear with no number. No line gives a print run like /25 or /99.

So for every card but the 1/1s, PSA’s list alone cannot tell a stolen copy from any other copy. PSA says it gave investigators "item-level records", which are not public.

If you are offered a 1/1 from the list

  1. Do not buy it, and do not confront the seller.
  2. Save the listing, the price and the seller’s details.
  3. Report it. PSA’s update asks for tips to go to the FBI:

If it is any other card on the list

Most cards on the list exist in many copies, so a raw copy proves nothing either way. As Resell Calendar puts it, "plenty of identical cards are listed on eBay right now by people who have nothing to do with the heist." The risk is a valuable raw copy with a vague story. Resell Calendar suggests three checks:

  1. When was the listing made? On eBay, a listing that has been edited shows a revision history. An edit before Oct 13 means the listing existed before the theft. Resell Calendar warns that this "only proves the listing existed, not that the card in hand is the same one".
  2. Can the seller show they had it before? Dated photos or a receipt from before Oct 13.
  3. Is the deal too good? Walk away from a valuable raw card offered at a discount with a vague backstory.

Our guide to checking a PSA slab covers the slabs, which are easier: their cert numbers are on the list.

Cracked and graded again

A cracked card may go back to PSA, or to another grading company, and come back in a new slab with a new cert number. That number will not be on PSA’s list, and PSA has not said whether it screens cards sent in again. Checking the cert still matters: a listed cert means the stolen slab, or a fake label copying its number. But a clear result on a new slab says nothing about where the card was before.

Check a cert now

Checks all 6,451 certs on PSA’s list. Paste one number or a list.

The number printed on the slab label.

Questions people ask

Can stolen PSA cards be sold raw?

Yes. A thief can crack the plastic case open and sell the card on its own. PSA deactivated the 6,451 cert numbers, and a cert number belongs to the case and its label, not the card. Resell Calendar notes that once a slab is cracked, there is nothing on most cards that ties them back to the theft.

Does PSA’s stolen list include serial numbers?

PSA says the list includes serial numbers for serialized cards. In the list itself, the only number given is 1/1, on 20 cards. 7 more slabs are marked serialized with no number, and no line gives a print run like /25 or /99. Owners have since reported the serial number and print run of 365 stolen slabs on a shared sheet, and our stolen list finds them when you search a serial such as 697/777.

Which stolen PSA cards can be traced without the slab?

From PSA’s list alone, only the 20 one-of-ones. A 1/1 that matches the list’s full description, meaning the year, set, card number and parallel, is very likely the stolen card. Owners have also reported the serial number and print run of 365 stolen slabs, so a raw numbered card whose card and serial match one of them is very likely the stolen copy. PSA has given investigators item-level records that are not public.

What if someone offers me a raw 1/1 card that is on the stolen list?

Do not buy it and do not confront the seller. Save the listing and the seller’s details and report it. PSA asks tips to go to the FBI’s Los Angeles office. Santa Ana police are also investigating.

Can a stolen card be graded again under a new cert number?

It may be sent in again, to PSA or another grading company, and come back with a cert number that is not on PSA’s list. PSA has not said whether it screens cards sent in again. A 1/1 from the list in a new slab is still worth reporting.

How do I buy a raw card safely right now?

For a raw copy of a card on the stolen list, ask when the seller got it. Resell Calendar suggests checking an eBay listing’s revision history for an edit before Oct 13, and asking for dated photos or a receipt. It also warns that an old listing only proves the listing existed, not that the card in hand is the same one.

Sources

  1. PSA theft updatepsacard.com
  2. PSA’s listassets.ctfassets.net
  3. Owners’ sheet (Boston Card Hunter)docs.google.com
  4. Resell Calendarresellcalendar.com

SlabHeist is independent and not affiliated with PSA or Collectors. Spotted an error? hello@slabheist.com

Keep reading

Check before you buy

Paste one cert or a list to see if it is on PSA’s stolen list. Or look through every stolen card.

Get case updates

One short email when the investigation moves or recovered slabs are named. Confirm by link, leave any time.

We save your sign-up now; confirmation emails start soon.