Buying slabs at a card show or in a break: check the certs first
Card shows and repack breaks are where stolen slabs can change hands for cash. How to check PSA cert numbers at the table, before a break and after a pull.
By SlabHeistPublished Facts as of 5 min read
On this page
Short version
- Check every slab’s cert number before cash changes hands. It takes seconds on a phone, and a whole list of certs takes one paste.
- At a show, read the number off the label or scan its barcode. For a big buy, ask for the cert numbers ahead and check them at home.
- Before a break, ask the breaker for the cert numbers of the slabs in it. After a pull, check the cert as soon as you can see it.
- If a cert is on PSA’s list, do not buy it and do not confront the seller. Report it.
Check every slab’s cert number before cash changes hands. At a card show, or before you buy into a break, it takes a few seconds on your phone. PSA (opens in a new tab) turned off the 6,451 cert numbers stolen from a FedEx truck on Oct 13, and published the list (opens in a new tab) on Oct 23. A slab whose number is on it is stolen, or wears a fake label that copies a stolen number.
As of Nov 9 we have seen no report of a slab from this theft at a show or in a break. But these are the places stolen cards have changed hands before. In an August report (opens in a new tab) on earlier thefts, a Mantel writer called card shows "the ultimate laundering mechanism for stolen inventory" and traced their own stolen PSA 10 to a repack break, where it was the top hit. The writer also noted that "virtually no one in the secondary supply chain is actively checking certification numbers against stolen databases".
Check a cert now
Checks all 6,451 certs on PSA’s list. Paste one number or a list.
At a card show
- Check before you pay, every time. Type the number from the label, or scan the label’s barcode with your phone. One to three certs come back in seconds.
- For a big buy, get the numbers ahead. Ask the dealer to send the cert numbers before the show. Paste them all at once, up to 500, and check them at home, where the signal is good.
- Check at PSA too. Stolen certs show as decertified at psacard.com/cert (opens in a new tab), Mantel reports (opens in a new tab). Use both checks. Make sure the card in the slab matches PSA’s record.
- Ask where a big card came from. Mantel’s advice for a grail sold "for cash below market value": ask where it came from. Walk away from a vague story.
- Keep a record. Copy result saves the answer with the date of PSA’s list and the time you checked. Keep it with your receipt.
If you are the dealer buying at your table
Walk-up sellers are the risk here. Mantel reported that a thief can visit several dealers at one show and "negotiate cash-in-hand sales at 70% to 80% of market value", with "no receipts, no photo IDs, no record of the exchange". Its advice to dealers and repackers buying from walk-up sellers:
- Run every cert before cash changes hands, at PSA and against a stolen list. Paste a seller’s whole stack into ours at once.
- For a big buy, ask for a name, an email address or some other paper trail.
- Ask where a six-figure card came from if it is offered for cash below market.
Before you buy into a break
A break sells spots in a box or a set of cards, opened live, often on Whatnot or Fanatics Live. If the break includes slabs, as repacks and slab breaks do:
- Ask the breaker for the cert numbers of the graded cards in it, and check them before you buy a spot. A breaker who opens only sealed product cannot list certs.
- Ask where the slabs came from. The breaker in Mantel’s story said it would "never knowingly" sell stolen cards, and that its suppliers buy from eBay, card shows and individual sellers, where "cards often change hands multiple times". That is why a check before the break matters more than the breaker’s good faith.
After you pull a slab
Check the cert as soon as you can read it on the stream, and again when the slab arrives. If it is on the list:
- Keep the slab as it is. Do not take the card out, and do not sell it on.
- Save the stream, the order and the breaker’s name.
- Tell the breaker and the platform. On Whatnot, Buyer Protection (opens in a new tab) gives sports cards and trading card games 7 days after delivery or 30 days after purchase, whichever comes first.
- Report it. PSA’s update asks for tips to go to the FBI:
Our guide on what to do if you bought a stolen PSA slab has the refund steps and each marketplace’s deadline.
What a check cannot tell you
A clear answer covers only this theft. A slab not on PSA’s list could still be stolen from somewhere else, or fake: a fake label can copy a real cert number. Our comparison of free checkers says which ones also hold other thefts, and our guide on how to spot a fake PSA slab has the label checks.
A raw card has no cert number at all. A thief can crack a slab and sell the card raw, and Resell Calendar (opens in a new tab) notes that for most cards nothing then ties them to the theft. See which stolen cards can still be traced raw.
A match is not proof the seller is a thief, either. On Oct 27 collectors found turned-off certs in one eBay store, and the listings turned out to be a victim’s own, made before the theft. Report what you saw and let the police sort it out.
Questions people ask
Have any slabs from the PSA FedEx theft turned up at a card show or in a break?
Not that we have seen, as of Nov 9. The only reported scare was a victim’s own eBay listings, made before the theft. But card shows and breaks are where stolen cards have changed hands before. In August, before this theft, a Mantel writer traced their own stolen PSA 10 to a repack break, where it was the top hit.
How do I check a lot of slabs at once at a card show?
Paste the cert numbers into our checker, up to 500 at a time, from a dealer’s list, a spreadsheet or a message. It drops repeats and skips numbers that are not certs. Copy result saves the answer with the date of PSA’s list and the time you checked.
What should I ask a breaker before I buy a spot?
Ask for the cert numbers of the graded cards in the break, then check them. A breaker who opens sealed product cannot list certs, but a repack or a slab break can. Ask where the slabs came from, too. One breaker told Mantel its suppliers buy from eBay, card shows and individual sellers, and that cards often change hands many times.
What if I pull a slab in a break and its cert is on the stolen list?
Keep it as it is. Do not open the case and do not sell it on. Tell the breaker and the platform the break ran on, save the stream and the order, and report the cert. PSA asks for tips to go to the FBI’s Los Angeles office. Some refund deadlines are only days, so start soon.
Someone wants to sell me slabs for cash at my table. What should I check?
Check every cert before you pay. Mantel warned that a thief can sell stolen slabs to several dealers at one show for cash, at 70% to 80% of market value, with no receipts and no ID. Its advice: run the certs, ask for a name or a paper trail on big buys, and ask where a grail came from if it is offered below market for cash.
Does a clear check mean a slab is safe to buy?
No. Our checker covers only the 6,451 certs from this theft. A slab that is not on the list could be stolen from somewhere else, or fake. Look the cert up at PSA too, and match the card to PSA’s record.
Sources
- Mantel (Aug 14, 2026)news.onmantel.com
- PSA theft updatepsacard.com
- PSA’s listassets.ctfassets.net
- Mantel on Yahoo Sportssports.yahoo.com
- Resell Calendarresellcalendar.com
- Whatnot Buyer Protectionhelp.whatnot.com
- psacard.com/certpsacard.com
SlabHeist is independent and not affiliated with PSA or Collectors. Spotted an error? hello@slabheist.com
Keep reading
Check before you buy
Paste one cert or a list to see if it is on PSA’s stolen list. Or look through every stolen card.
How to check if a PSA slab is stolen
Six quick steps before you buy a PSA slab, and who to call if its cert number is on PSA’s list of stolen cards.
Bought a stolen PSA slab? What to do now
The cert on a slab you bought is on PSA’s stolen list. Keep it as it is, report it, and ask for your money back before the marketplace’s deadline runs out.
PSA cert lookup: how to look up a PSA cert number
Where the cert number is on a PSA slab, how to look it up and verify it on PSA’s site or app, what the record shows, why it may not work, and if it was stolen.
Free ways to check if a PSA slab is stolen
The free tools that check a PSA cert for theft, side by side: what each costs, if it needs an account, and if it has PSA’s list from the October 2026 theft.
Stolen PSA cards sold raw: which ones can still be traced
A stolen slab can be cracked open and the card sold raw. Out of the slab, only 1/1s and numbered cards whose serial numbers owners reported can be matched.
How to spot a fake PSA slab
A fake PSA slab can copy a real cert number. Seven checks before you pay: PSA’s own photos, the label’s codes and security marks, the case, and the stolen list.
How to tell if a Pokémon card is fake
Six checks for a fake Pokémon card, from the card back to the print, which tests the experts disagree on, fake packs, and what to do if the card is in a slab.
PSA reholder: what it costs, and old certs in new holders
A PSA reholder puts a card in PSA’s latest case and label with the same grade and cert number. What it costs, what PSA checks, and old certs in new holders.
PSA grading scale: what each grade from 1 to 10 means
PSA grades cards from 1 to 10. What each grade allows, its centering limit, half grades, qualifiers, and what a PSA 10 is worth over a 9 on the stolen cards.
What was stolen in the PSA truck heist
PSA’s list of 6,451 stolen items, counted: 3,913 different cards, 60% Pokémon or One Piece, 72% from the 2020s, and up to 51 copies of one card.
Will PSA pay for cards stolen in the FedEx theft?
Yes, if it shipped on PSA’s return label: PSA pays each stolen card’s market value up to its Maximum Insured Value, and refunds grading fees.
PSA heist timeline: the FedEx truck theft, day by day
From the Oct 13 break-in to PSA’s list of 6,451 stolen items: what happened each day, who said it, and where reports disagree.